Methods: Between January 1958 and July 2010, national and international databases were scanned to reach articles on PAP in Turkey and full texts were reviewed. Demographic characteristics of patients, clinical data, laboratory findings, imaging studies, diagnostic methods and treatments were recorded.
Results: Twenty-two articles reporting 24 cases were found in the literature. The mean age was 21±14 years (range, 1 day to 47 years). Thoracic computed tomography revealed crazy paving appearance in nine patients, ground glass appearance in five patients, and infection in two patients. Nine patients underwent transbronchial biopsy (TBB), while 10 underwent open lung biopsy (OLB). Diagnosis was based on autopsy in three cases, bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF) in two cases, TBB in four cases, OLB in nine cases, BALF and TBB in three cases, BALF and electron microscopy (EM) in one case, BALF, EM and TBB in one case, and BALF, EM and OLB in one case. Whole lung lavage was performed on six cases, while four cases underwent segmental bronchial lavage. One case was treated with intravenous immunoglobulin, while one case was treated with granulocyte colony stimulating factor. Five cases died during hospitalization. Chest X-ray revealed improved hypoxia in four cases, improved lung function test results in three cases and regressed lesions in five cases.
Conclusion: Our study results suggest that diagnostic and management approaches for Turkish patients with PAP are consistent with the published materials in the literature.
Table 1: The list of pulmonary alveolar proteinosis cases reported from Turkey
Table 2: Demographic information of the Turkish patients with pulmonary alveolar proteinosis
Symptoms
Dyspnea was observed in 23 of the cases, cough in
17, fever in nine, sputum in five, chest pain in three,
weight loss in three, leg swelling in two, and hemoptysis in one. The median symptom duration time was five
months (range five minutes to 48 months).
Physical examinations
Fourteen cases had crackles at the lung bases, 12
had cyanosis, four had clubbing, four had subcostal
retractions, two had lower extremity edema, and one
had hepatosplenomegaly. However, normal results were
reported in four of the cases on physical examination.
Misdiagnosis and comorbidities
Seven cases had received antituberculous treatment
before the diagnosis of PAP, but none had a proven
microbiology for acid-fast bacilli (AFB). In addition,
sputum smears for AFB were examined in 14 cases
during hospitalization, and none had positive results.
Five cases were diagnosed with unresolved pneumonia,
and one case had idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis.
Interstitial lung disease was also detected before the
diagnosis of PAP in one of the cases. Furthermore,
one had been exposed to welding smoke and one
to both asbestos and welding smoke. Agricultural
particles were also found in three of the cases while
one had previously undergone a lobectomy due to
bronchiectasis and unresponsiveness to antituberculous
treatment. There was also one case of amyloidosis,
one with a combination of amyloidosis and nephrotic
syndrome, one with acute lympocytic leukemia (ALL),
and another with agammaglobulinemia.
Laboratory findings
Five of the cases had normal laboratory findings,
but no details were reported. However, we were able
to obtain the detailed laboratory results in 10 of the
cases. The mean white blood cell (WBC) count was
10,750±1,061 (range 5,100 to 15,200), the erythrocyte
sedimentation rate (ESR) was 53±42 mm/hr (range 5
to 130 mm/hr), and the lactate dehydrogenase (LDH)
level was 1,001±107 U/L (range 401 to 3,283 U/L).
Fourteen of the 15 cases had hypoxia on arterial
blood gas analysis. Diffusing capacity of the lung for
carbon monoxide (DLCO) tests were conducted on six
of the cases, with three reporting severe results, two
moderate, and one mildly diminished. Spirometry was
performed on 13 cases. Four had mild reduction, three
moderate, and four had severe reduction on pulmonary
function tests (PFTs) with a restrictive pattern. The
results were as follows: mean FEV1 (%): 76.5±14.7
(range, 52-101%), mean FVC (%): 58.5±17.5 (range,
50-99%), and mean FEV1/FVC (%): 89.3±5.9 (range,
80-99.5%) (Table 3).
Radiology
Twenty-three cases underwent chest-X rays, and
bilateral infiltrations were reported in all of them.
Eleven cases had diffuse, nine had perihilar, and three
had dominant consolidations in the lower lung zone.
In addition, 16 of the cases underwent chest computed
tomography (CT), and all of them had bilateral findings.
Nine cases had crazy-paving patterns, five had ground
glass appearance and two had concurrent infection
findings. (Table 3).
Diagnosis
Fiberoptic bronchoscopy (FOB) was performed on
14 cases, and bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF)
analysis were performed on all of them. Electron
microscopy (EM) was also performed on four of the
cases, nine cases underwent transbronchial biopsy
(TBB), and 10 had an open lung biopsy (OLB). The
diagnosis of PAP was done by autopsy in three cases,
BALF in two, TBB in four, OLB in nine, BALF and
TBB in three, BAL and EM; BALF, EM and TBB;
BALF, EM and OLB; each combination in single cases
(Table 4).
Treatments
Six cases underwent WLL, and four underwent
segmental bronchial lavage. Furthermore, one case
was treated with intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG)
and another with granulocyte colony stimulating factor
(G-CSF) (Table 4).
Outcomes
Five cases died during hospitalization, and four
had improved hypoxia in blood gas analysis. Three of
the cases also had improved lung function test results
while five had regression of the lesions on chest X-ray.
Child cases
Four of the cases were male children who were
one day, two and a half months, 13 months, and four
years old. The 13-month-old boy was investigated
for interstitial lung disease because his parents had
a history of consanguineous marriage, and an open
lung biopsy was conducted to obtain a diagnosis.
Underwater closed drainage was performed, but the
patient had to be intubated for respiratory insufficiency
and died on the fourth day of intubation.[4]
The four-year-old boy had previously received treatment for pneumonia and tuberculosis. The diagnosis was made by OLB, and he had hypoxia at hospitalization. Whole lung lavage therapy was performed 12 times during the follow-up period, and he was reported to have less oxygen dependence after the WLL therapies.[5]
The first newborn suffered from respiratory insufficiency after the 12th h our o f b irth. Bronchopulmonary infiltrations were observed on chest X-ray, and he died after the 73rd day of hospitalization. Pulmonary alveolar proteinosis was diagnosed after the autopsy. Even though his parents had a history of consanguineous marriage and received a genetic consultation, they had another baby boy after a year. The second newborn baby boy had respiratory insufficiency and was intubated, but he died 30 minutes after being born. An autopsy was performed, and he was also diagnosed with PAP. In addition, an increase in the number of cells expressing surfactan apoprotein A (SP-A), which could have been a sign of surfactin apoprotein B (SP-B) deficiency, was observed in an immunohistological examination of the lung tissue.[6]
Pulmonary alveolar proteinosis has also been associated with immune deficiencies, such as agammaglobulinemia, combined immunodeficiency, and organ transplantation. Moreover, hematological disorders, including acute myeloid leukemia, myeleodysplastic syndromes, acute lymphoid leukemia, lymphoma, and myeloma can also cause PAP. Patients may be neutropenic secondary to chemotherapy, and infectious pathogens may be isolated from the BALF. Additionally, respiratory insufficiency and fever can be observed in PAP patients, and lung cancer may also may be associated with this disease.[27]
In our Turkish cases, one had immune deficiency (agammaglobulinemia) and another had a hemotological disorder (acute lymphocytic leukemia precursor B cell type). The first was diagnosed at the age of eight via an open lung biopsy. The patient was hospitalized three times, and WLL was performed. She was reported to be alive three years after the diagnosis and asymptomatic.[7] Febril neutropenia was reported in the second case after the 38th d ay of chemotherapy. A fter receiving antibiotics and GM-CSF, the lesions were no longer visible on high-resolution computed tomography (HRCT), but the patient died a year later from a relapse of acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL).[8]
Pulmonary alveolar proteinosis may also be connected with the inhalation of mineral, metal, or organic particles. In French and Japanese studies, 23-39% of PAP patients reported exposure to these types of particles.[27] In this study, we found six cases (25%) of toxic particle inhalation, one of which was attributed to asbestos, two to welding smoke, and three to agricultural particles.
Surfactant mutations and genetic defects in the GM-CSF receptor along with lysinuric protein intolerance can cause the genetic PAP subtype.
In addition, the homozygous frame shift mutation in the porcine surfactant protein B (SFTPB) gene can cause congenital PAP, and altered distribution of the SFTPA gene has been observed in lung specimens.[28] We confirmed SP-B deficiency in one of cases after an autopsy, and the brother of this patient who had died a year earlier had also been diagnosed with PAP.[6]
Signs-Physical examination
Pulmonary alveolar proteinosis usually presents
with dyspnea, cough, weight loss, chest pain,
hemopthysis, and malaise. Fever and hemopthysis
can be signs of accompanying infection. A physical
examination is often normal, but crackles may be
observed at the lung bases along with cyanosis and
clubbing.[29] In the Turkish cases that we examined,
the symptoms were reported as follows: dyspnea (96%), cough (71%), fever (38%), sputum (21%), chest
pain (13%), weight loss (13%), leg swelling (8%), and
hemopthysis (4%). Six cases had received antibiotics
during their hospitalization. In four of the cases (17%),
normal physical findings were reported, but there
were fourteen cases (58%) of crackles at the lung
bases, 12 (50%) of cyanosis, four (17%) of clubbing,
four (17%) of subcostal retractions, two (8%) of lower
extremity edema, and one (4%) of hepatosplenomegaly.
Radiology
Conducting a chest X-ray is the first step toward
diagnosing PAP, but it demonstrates nonspecific
signs. However, ground glass and reticulonodular
opacities that are symmetrical and perihilar in nature
along with consolidations with air bronchograms and
diffuse bilateral infiltrations in all lung fields can
be observed via this method. Chest X-rays can also
reveal apical lung fields and costophrenic sinuses that
have been preserved. The radiological appearance of
PAP resembles pulmonary interstitial edema without
pleural effusion and cardiomegaly. In addition, pleural
effusion, lymphadenopathy, and cavitary lesions can
be observed in accompanying pulmonary infections.[29]
In this study, we found that in 23 cases who underwent
chest X-rays, 11 (48%) had diffuse consolidations, nine
(39%) had perihilar consolidations, and three (13%)
had dominant consolidations in the lower lung zone.
Computed tomography is better for revealing the anatomy and showing the extension of PAP disease. Crazy-paving appearance refers to the ground glass opacity with septal thickening. This sign is generally bilateral and diffuse with the unaffected lung fields identified by sharp borders. On CT, crazy paving can be diffuse or regional as well as symmetrical or asymmetrical. Sixteen cases in this study had chest CT results. Nine (56%) had crazy paving, five (31%) had ground glass opacity, and two (13%) had superposition of infection pattern. Lung function capacity is related to the extent of ground glass appearance and consolidation. Although crazy paving is typical in PAP, it can also be observed in various infectious, hemorrhagic, or neoplastic conditions, including left ventricular insufficiency, pneumonia, alveolar hemorrhage, bronchoalveolar carcinoma, and diffuse alveolar injury.
Diagnosis
The milky appearance in the BALF is typical
for PAP, and an examination showed of this fluid
showed PAS-positive fields in the alveoli. Furthermore,
foamy macrophages can be observed microscopically.
Lamellar bodies on electron microscopy can also confirm the diagnosis of PAP. When unsatisfactory
BALF is obtained, transbronchial or open lung biopsies
are sometimes performed.[29]
In this retrospective study, BALF was obtained in 14 cases (58%) while 10 (42%) underwent an open lung biopsy. Additionally, transbronchial biopsies were performed on nine cases (38%), and electron microscopy confirmation was needed in four others. (17%). Three cases (13%) were also diagnosed after an autopsy.
Hypoxia is due to alveolar depositions which affect the transport of oxygen from the alveoli. High levels of LDH have also been reported as a disease severity marker.[30,31]
Sixteen of our cases reported the presence of LDH. Ten (63%) of these had elevated LDH levels while six were within the normal range.
Spirometry reveals a restrictive pattern when hypoxemia and reduced DLCO are observed in PAP cases.[27] Of the 13 cases that we evaluated who had spirometry results, two (15%) reported normal findings while four (31%) had mild, three (23%) had moderate, and four (31%) had severe reduction. Only six of the cases had DLCO test results. Mild reduction was reported in one case, with moderate reduction in two others, and severe reduction in the other three.
Serum surfactant protein SP-A, SP-B and SP-D levels are increased in PAP.[9] One of the Turkish cases had SP-A expression in a histological specimen and was diagnosed with PAP after an autopsy.
Elevated concentrations of iron, transferrin, transferrin receptor, lactoferrin, and ferritin have been observed in the alveolar space in recent studies.[28] In our study, the baby boy who was diagnosed with PAP via an autopsy also had liver hemosderosis and extramedullary hematopoiesis, and his brother, who was born a year later and died 30 minutes after being born, was also diagnosed with genetic PAP.[6]
Treatment
Although spontaneous remission is observed in
some patients, WLL is the recognized standard of care
for PAP patients with respiratory symptoms.[29] After
general anesthesia and double lumen intubation, large
amounts of warmed sterile saline in 1-2 liter doses for
a total of up to 15 to 60 liters are administered through
the tube to one lung while single lung ventilation is
performed on the other side. By mechanical washing
of the lung with saline and percussion to the chest, the
excess amount of material from the alveoli, which is
composed of surfactant, is removed. When the BALF becomes clear, the procedure is ended. However, it
may be necessary for the contralateral lung to be
lavaged one or two days later. In addition, WLL can be
performed at various times when indicated, but it must
be performed once only one lung at a time.
Thirteen of the cases (54%) in our study received nonspecific treatments, for example antibiotics, steroids, or oxygen support, or they were merely observed. Whole lung lavage was eventually performed in six of these cases (25%), and segmental lung lavage in four others (17%). Additionally, one of the cases (4%) was treated with IVIG while GM-CSF was used in another (4%).
Therapy with GM-CSF is another treatment choice via either inhalation or the subcutaneous route. In the study by Borie et al.,[27] improvement was observed with this type of treatment in PAP patients (48% to 68%) when used in the autoimmune subtype. Therefore, GM-CSF is considered to be an alternative choice to WLL. The case who received GM-CSF in our study also had a hematological malignancy. In a study by Şimşek et al.,[10] HRCT revealed that the infiltrations disappeared after this treatment option. The case who received IVIG therapy had agammaglobulinemia, and WLL was also performed along with the use of GM-CSF. The hypoxia then improved, and the lung infiltrations diminished afterwards.[7]
Prognosis
Spontaneous remission can be observed in the
autoimmune subtype of PAP, as was seen in 10 of 15
asymptomatic untreated patients in a French cohort and
11 of 39 patients in a Japanese cohort.[32,33] Whole lung
lavage therapy and GM-CSF may be beneficial, but
some patients do not respond to any type of therapy.
However, the five-year survival rate for autoimmune
PAP with WLL is nearly 95%.[27]
Five of the cases in our study died during hospitalization, but four with a hypoxic condition improved and were discharged from the hospital. Furthermore, three cases showed improved lung function tests, and five had regression of the lesions on chest X-ray. Thirteen of the cases who were discharged from hospital were reported to be under follow-up periods ranging from three months to four years.
Limitations
The cases that we reported in this study were all
full text articles. During the study period, we also
found some cases on internet search engines that had
been reported in national congresses as thematic poster
sessions. Since these may have been in congresses held by different specialties, it was not possible to
find all of these cases nor could we always contact the
presenters. Information presented in poster sessions is
often limited, thus these PAP cases may not have been
reported in journals. Moreover, we believe that PAP
disease is underdiagnosed in Turkey as there are a
relatively small number of reported cases for a country
that has a population of approximately 74 million.
In conclusion, 24 Turkish PAP cases were reviewed in this study. Dyspnea, cough, and fever were the most reported symptoms, and crackles at the lung bases and cyanosis were the most common physical findings. Chest X-rays and CT were used as the preferred imaging techniques in these cases, and different types of diagnostic procedures (EM, BALF, TBB, OLB) and therapies (WLL, BAL, IVIG, GM-CSF) were applied that corresponded to the those used in the published data. Five cases died during hospitalization, four reported improved hypoxia, three had improved lung function test results, and five had regression of the lesions on chest X-ray. Interestingly, seven of the adult PAP cases had previously received antituberculous treatment, which might because of the high prevalence of tuberculosis (TB) in Turkey. Some of the PAP patients did not respond to antibiotic therapy, which was surprising since the imaging findings indicated that this treatment was necessary. For this reason, in some cases, invasive procedures might have to be performed to diagnosis PAP.
Declaration of conflicting interests
The authors declared no conflicts of interest with
respect to the authorship and/or publication of this
article.
Funding
The authors received no financial support for the
research and/or authorship of this article.
1) Seymour JF, Presneill JJ. Pulmonary alveolar proteinosis:
progress in the first 44 years. Am J Respir Crit Care Med
2002;166:215-35.
2) Trapnell BC, Carey BC, Uchida K, Suzuki T. Pulmonary
alveolar proteinosis, a primary immunodeficiency of
impaired GM-CSF stimulation of macrophages. Curr Opin
Immunol 2009;21:514-21. doi: 10.1016/j.coi.2009.09.004.
3) Goerpe A, Kuyumcuyan K, Ercan H, Ozkan E. Pulmonary
alveolar proteinosis. (apropos of 2 cases). [Article in Turkish]
Tip Fak Mecm 1964;27:72-9.
4) Hızarcıoğlu M, Kayserili E, Ecevit Ç, Gülez P, Apa H,
Ortaç R. Pulmoner alveolar proteinozisli bir olgu. Pulmonary
alveolar proteinosis: a case report. Ege Ped Bül 2003;10:151-4.
5) Doğru D, Yalçin E, Aslan AT, Ocal T, Ozçelik U, Güçer S, et al. Successful unilateral partial lung lavage in a child with
pulmonary alveolar proteinosis. J Clin Anesth 2009;21:127-30. doi: 10.1016/j.jclinane.2008.06.035.
6) Meşe T, Dizdarer C, Aktaş S, Özcan T, Ülker Ü. Konjenital
pulmoner alveoler proteinozis (İki kardeşte olgu sunumu).
Türkiye Ekopatoloji Dergisi 2003;9:81-4.
7) Patiroglu T, Akyildiz B, Patiroglu TE, Gulmez IY.
Recurrent pulmonary alveolar proteinosis secondary to
agammaglobulinemia. Pediatr Pulmonol 2008;43:710-3. doi:10.1002/ppul.20818.
8) Pamuk GE, Turgut B, Vural O, Demir M, Hatipoğlu O, Unlü
E, et al. Pulmonary alveolar proteinosis in a patient with
acute lymphoid leukemia regression after G-CSF therapy.
Leuk Lymphoma 2003;44:871-4.
9) Özdemir N, Ardıç S, Tel T, Ekici M, Metintaş M, Çerezci V
ve ark. Parankim fibrozisinin eşlik ettiği pulmoner alveoler
proteinozis. Solunum Hastalıkları 1991;2:55-60.
10) Şimşek C, Kalaycıoğlu O, Beder S, Tunç M, Evirgen
O, Ertürk Ş. Kaynakçı siderozisi ve pulmoner alveoler
proteinozis (bir olgu sunusu). Turkiye Klinikleri J Med Sci
1992;12:250-3.
11) Baran R, Aksoy F, Ertan FÜ, Özyaran K, Tor M. Pulmoner
alveoler proteinozis balgam incelemesi ve segmental lavaj ile
tanı. Pulmonary alveolar proteinosis: diagnosis by sputum
examination and segmental lavage. Solunum 1994;19:688-92.
12) Köktürk N, Oğuzülgen İK, Türktaş H, Ahmet Mahli A.
A case report: Pulmonary alveolar proteinosis. Turkish
Respiratory Journal 2000;1:68-72.
13) Kaçar N, Ünsal Ş, Çakan A, Tuksavul F, Ermete S, Güçlü SZ.
Pulmoner alveoler proteinozis (Olgu sunumu). Tüberküloz ve
Toraks Dergisi 2000;48:162-6.
14) Çiftçi TU, Şipit T, Apaydın Z, Çoban G, Oğuz D. Pulmoner
alveoler proteinozis (PAP) (Bir olgu nedeniyle). Solunum
Hastalıkları 2001;12:71-4.
15) Seyfikli Z, Gönlüuğur U, Berk S, Arıcı S, Kap M. Primary
alveolar proteinosis and review of the literature. Turkish
Respiratory Journal 2001;2:36-9.
16) Gülsüm M, Arıyürek M, Başaran Demirkazık F, Fırat
P. Yüksek rezolüsyonlu bilgisayarlı tomografide Arnavut
kaldırımı görünümü oluşturan bronşioloalveoler kanser ve
pulmoner alveoler proteinozis: İki olgu sunumu. Bilgisayarlı
Tomografi Bülteni 2002;7:38-40.
17) Polat G, Yılmaz U, Yalnız E, Ermete S, Utkaner G. Pulmoner
alveoler proteinozis (olgu sunumu). İzmir Göğüs Hastanesi
Dergisi 2003;17:73-7.
18) Sazak HG, Göktaş U, Alagöz A, Gülhan M, Şahan L,
Şavkılıoğlu E ve ark. Pulmoner alveoler proteinozis
uygulanan masif bronkoalveoler lavajda anestezi (olgu
sunumu). GKD Anest Yoğ Bak Dern Derg 2003;9:77-81.
19) Sancak S, Karakurt S, Ceyhan B, Çelikel T. Bronkoalveoler
lavaj sonrası ARDS gelişen pulmoner alveoler proteinozisli hasta. Yoğun Bakım Dergisi 2004;4:195-9.
20) Gavaf M, Karasu I, Çakan A, Özsöz A, Aydoğdu Z.
Pulmoner alveoler proteinozis (olgu sunumu). İzmir Göğüs
Hastanesi Dergisi 2007;21:41-6.
21) Edis EC, Tabakoglu E, Caglar T, Hatipoglu ON, Cevirme
L, Alagol A. Treatment of a primary pulmonary alveolar
proteinosis case with severe hypoxaemia by using
segmental lavage technique. Ann Acad Med Singapore
2007;36:871-2.
22) Uyar M, Elbek O, Çiftçi N, Şanlı M, Bakır K, Dikensoy Ö.
Fatal seyirli pulmoner alveoler proteinozis. Tur Toraks Der
2008;9:177-80.
23) Tutar N, Gülmez İ, Hasdıraz L, Büyükoğlan H, Demir R,
Oymak FS ve ark. Pulmoner alveoler proteinozis (vaka
sunumu). Solunum 2009;11:43-5.
24) Yildiz T, Ates G, Bogatekin G, Ozmen CA, Mizrak B. A case
of idiopathic pulmonary alveolar proteinosis. Respiratory
Medicine CME 2010;3:267-9.
25) Rosen SH, Castleman B, Liebow AA. Pulmonary alveolar
proteinosis. N Engl J Med 1958;258:1123-42.
26) Kitamura T, Tanaka N, Watanabe J, Uchida, Kanegasaki S,
Yamada Y, et al. Idiopathic pulmonary alveolar proteinosis
as an autoimmune disease with neutralizing antibody against
granulocyte/macrophage colony-stimulating factor. J Exp
Med 1999;190:875-80.
27) Borie R, Danel C, Debray MP, Taille C, Dombret MC, Aubier
M, et al. Pulmonary alveolar proteinosis. Eur Respir Rev
2011;20:98-107. doi: 10.1183/09059180.00001311.
28) Huizar I, Kavuru MS. Alveolar proteinosis syndrome:
pathogenesis, diagnosis, and management. Curr Opin Pulm
Med 2009;15:491-8. doi: 10.1097/MCP.0b013e32832ea51c.
29) Vancheeswaren R, Morgan C, Wells AU. Pulmonary alveolar
proteinosis. Investigation and management- a review. Clin
Pulm Med 2007;14:360-4.
30) Hoffman RM, Rogers RM. Serum and lavage lactate
dehydrogenase isoenzymes in pulmonary alveolar proteinosis.
Am Rev Respir Dis 1991;143:42-6.
31) Seymour JF, Doyle IR, Nakata K, Presneill JJ, Schoch OD,
Hamano E, et al Thorax. Relationship of anti-GM-CSF
antibody concentration, surfactant protein A and B levels,
and serum LDH to pulmonary parameters and response
to GM-CSF therapy in patients with idiopathic alveolar
proteinosis. Thorax 2003;58:252-7.